The Xbox Live Fan Posting Competition is currently underway.. Find Out More!
The Xbox Live Fan Prize Prize is currently open for new entrants.. Find Out More!
The Xbox Live Fan Popular Member Competition has opened up for new members to enter.. Find Out More!
Tickets for the XLF$ Lottery (With Special Prize) are now on sale.. Find Out More!
The XLF$ Shop is now open and all orders can be placed.. Find Out More!

Forum rules


All the reviews in this forum have been done by our very own XLF Reviewers. You can request a game review to be done by one of our reviewers by visiting The XLF Team forum and asking one of them to do it. You can view a complete list of all the games reviewed on the Xbox & Kinect Game Reviews: A-Z page. You can not create new topics in this forum, but you can reply to the ones already here. Any posts that break our rules will be removed and the member posting it will be given a warning. If a member accumulates 3 warnings at any one time, they will be banned for life! Each warning given also comes with a 100 XLF Cash deduction for the member receiving it.



Reply to topic  [ 14 posts ] 
 Portal 2 (46.6/50) 
Author Message
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
XboxLiveFan.org Game Review On...
Portal 2
Buy This Game From Amazon.co.uk


Game Title: Portal 2
Game Genre: Puzzle-Platformer
Console(s): Xbox 360, PS3, PC
Publisher: Valve
Developer: Valve
Date Released: April 19th - 21st, 2011
Retail Price: $29.99 USD (Amazon.com)
Age Rating:: ACB: PG - ESRB: E10+ -PEGI: 12
Players: 2 players max.
Co-Op: Yes
Achievements: 50 known achievements
Xbox Live Compatable: Yes
Online Multiplayer: Yes
Xbox System Link: No
HDTV Support: Yes
Previous Edition: Portal

Visuals & Graphics..
The visuals of Portal II are outstanding as usual with the textures much sharper and rendered than the first. Mostly due to the fact that you are running about in the catwalks behind the chambers, the objects and the pathways have to be easily spotted from a distance. Its much like the environment in Half Life 2 got a nice polish to look even better.

But moreover, it allows you to see how much the facility has changed since the first game. In the first few moments, you can see growing plants and other foliage poking through the dirty tiles of the test chambers. Much like the mold stuff that's currently growing along the walls of your shower. It's a nice contrast to when you walk through the test chambers again when GLaDOS restores most of them to their clean and sparkly white state. The deep toxic water looks as discouraging as the first and it still kills you. It's nice how some things are still constant, isn't it?

The only bad thing about this is from a distance, even some portal-able walls are still hard to see, but overall aesthetics are still great and give the facility a nice atmosphere.
Visuals & Graphics Rating: 9.8/10

Achievement Difficulty..
The achievements aren't hard to get not especially if you have a nice friend to play Portal with online or just a nice friend in general to sit with you through the entire playthrough of Portal. Co-op is surprisingly fun to sit through and you are encouraged by GLaDOs herself to kill your partner in a variety of ways. Which is great if you're getting annoyed with them.
Otherwise they're pretty easy to achieve. And you can have fun doing so.
Achievement Difficulty Rating: 9.5/10

Story Mode / Campaign Difficulty..
The campaign isn't difficult at all unless you're either not good at physics or you are naturally horrible at puzzle games. Portal isn't a brain training game, but it does require some thought at how you'd solve puzzles. The enemies aren't hard at all and all you'd normally need to do is to flank them by any means necessary and to just drop them onto their side, drop them off a sizable ledge that acts like a cliff, dropping cubes on them and the list goes on. And should you fail in something and end up dying, death is pretty instantaneous so you don't have to worry about a long death sequence and then the really long game reload.
Story Mode / Campaign Difficulty Rating: 9.5/10

Game Depth & Navigation Details..
The depth of the story is not that hard to pick up on and often you're more preoccupied in the test chambers to keep track of the overall story. However, it follows pretty much the events of the first story and the final boss fight is pretty much the same.

Navigation isn't too sticky as you really have no need for an in game menu or an inventory screen so, swapping of portals is really a button press away. Getting stuck in Portals is usually confusing but easy to solve. Best not to try and solve it next to a ledge though. That might just confuse the utter hell out of you like it did with me.

Co-op has the added feature of gestures which are selected through a system similar to the shortcut inventory dial in Dragon Age: Origins. It's not a hassle if you accidentally press it. And most of the gestures you perform will result in a reply from GLaDOS about getting back to work or a fun animation from your character.
Storyline Depth & Navigation Details Rating: 9.6/10

Value For Money..
Portal II is not so much a value for money game as most fans will play it for a specific part or moment.
Spoiler:
Like when GLaDOS is turned into a potato but still has a whole bunch of her usual lines.
"Oh, Hi. So How are you holding up? BECAUSE I'M A POTATO!"
" I hope you brought something stronger than a portal gun this time. Otherwise, I'm afraid you're about to become the immediate past president of the Being Alive Club. Ha, ha."
I find it hard to sit through the game again as there's not much that really changes. You run through the same storyline and do the same puzzles. So this is where it might lose a few points with me.
Spoiler:
I do find that the both of them (Wheatley and GLaDOS) are scared of a bird in the game. Hilarity ensues when Wheatley makes the mistake of dropping the birds eggs into the door. Ah. Good ol' Wheatley.
Value For Money Rating: 8.2/10

Ratings Round-Up..
Visuals & Graphics: 9.8/10
Achievement Difficulty: 9.5/10
Story Mode / Campaign Difficulty: 9.5/10
Game Depth & Navigation Details: 9.6/10
Value For Money: 8.2/10

Overall Rating: 46.6/50

Image Image Image


XLF Reviewer: Deadpool

To view the Xbox Game Reviews A-Z, Click Here!
To buy this game from Amazon.co.uk, simply Click Here!
To visit the main Xbox Game Reviews forum, Click Here!

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Wed Aug 29, 2012 9:28 am
Profile WWW
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
30.2%

Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2012 2:06 pm
XLF Wallet 144.23 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 0.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 651
Location: Michigan
Blog: View Blog (3)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: N/A
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: N/A
Worst Game: N/A
If I had an xbox this would definitely help me consider playing or trying out Portal II

_________________
Image


Thu Sep 13, 2012 6:41 am
Profile
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
DeadpoolsGal wrote:
If I had an xbox this would definitely help me consider playing or trying out Portal II

The cross platforming is very handy too. So you could play it on a PS3 or PC and still be able to play with your friends too. :cheesygrin:

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Thu Sep 13, 2012 1:43 pm
Profile WWW
Ultimate Fan
Ultimate Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
18.6%

Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:46 am
XLF Wallet 1,652.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 13,215.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 2557
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Missriddles
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: Borderlands
Worst Game: Facebreaker
I didn't like Portal 1 (played it for a few hours) so would you say that I couldn't enjoy Portal 2 either? Or could I? :D

_________________
Image


Thu Sep 13, 2012 3:19 pm
Profile
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
MissRiddlez wrote:
I didn't like Portal 1 (played it for a few hours) so would you say that I couldn't enjoy Portal 2 either? Or could I? :D

It would depend what you didn't like about Portal I. If it was gameplay, then probably not. xD
I really liked Portal II for its witty and funny instances. :P

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Mon Sep 17, 2012 2:13 am
Profile WWW
Ultimate Fan
Ultimate Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
18.6%

Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:46 am
XLF Wallet 1,652.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 13,215.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 2557
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Missriddles
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: Borderlands
Worst Game: Facebreaker
Well I don't really know what I didn't like about it :D Generally it just didn't feel interesting to me. It seemed to have no point :P

_________________
Image


Mon Sep 17, 2012 5:26 am
Profile
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
42%
1 year of membership
Joined: Thu Feb 23, 2012 5:12 pm
XLF Wallet 24.28 XLF Cash

Posts: 21
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: n/a
Console: n/a
Accessory: n/a
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Turok Evolution
@MissRiddlez - Second in a series of games never are as good as the first I find.
Normally because the second is just a continuation from the first, and they've used up all their ideas in the first game, without thought for the second.
I personally haven't player Portal 2, but I presume it is similar to the above statement.

Second games don't have an originality and a uniqueness unlike the first in a series.


Mon Sep 17, 2012 9:06 am
Profile
Ultimate Fan
Ultimate Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
18.6%

Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:46 am
XLF Wallet 1,652.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 13,215.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 2557
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Missriddles
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: Borderlands
Worst Game: Facebreaker
You are right about that. But there have been sequels that are better than the first, take Assassins Creed for example. Try to play the first now, after you've played the second :D It's painful.
Maybe I need to take another look at Portal, then I know for sure

_________________
Image


Mon Sep 17, 2012 3:02 pm
Profile
Growing Up
Growing Up
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
6%

Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2012 8:25 pm
XLF Wallet 10,031.60 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 0.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 53
Location: Earth
Blog: View Blog (1)
Gamertag: BigJKGamer
Console: Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Microsoft Kinect
Fav Game: London 2012
Worst Game: FIFA 13
i really like the images on this review. the review is also got, the images making it better. looks very techie :D


Wed Nov 14, 2012 8:21 am
Profile WWW
Growing Up
Growing Up
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
52%
1 year of membership
Joined: Mon Feb 20, 2012 8:43 pm
XLF Wallet 60.42 XLF Cash

Posts: 76
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: N/A
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: N/A
Worst Game: N/A
I've never played Portal 2 but I've only heard good things about it. I have a friend that loves Portal and Portal 2! Some day I might get it.

_________________
Image
TheMarioForums.com


Fri Nov 16, 2012 4:27 am
Profile
Growing Up
Growing Up
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
52%

Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2012 11:54 am
XLF Wallet 563.90 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 268.77 XLF Cash

Posts: 76
Location: Ask
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: oXBoxerXo
Console: 360
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: FIFA 13
Worst Game: PES 2013
I really like the photos in this review, i havent played the game, but the photos are really good and the review quite too

_________________
! XbOxEr !


Thu Jan 24, 2013 11:15 pm
Profile
Regular Fan
Regular Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.7%

Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:06 pm
XLF Wallet 683.51 XLF Cash

Posts: 149
Location: Planet E
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: GTA IV
Worst Game: N/A
I never liked this games, played portal 1, was just a crap, i don't know about this one.


Wed Mar 06, 2013 4:17 pm
Profile WWW
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
60%

Joined: Sat Mar 16, 2013 10:04 pm
XLF Wallet 207.57 XLF Cash

Posts: 30
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: jackattack923
I was disappointed in the lack of replay value myself. I hope that if a Portal 3 comes out, that they will try and add some more.

Also, on a small note, when you add up the totals it is a 46.6/50. :wink:


Sun Mar 17, 2013 10:28 pm
Profile
Site Admin
Site Admin
User avatar
Ultimate Fan
Ultimate FanProgress to next rank:
17.7%
1 year of membership
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 6:07 am
XLF Wallet 310.37 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 471.24 XLF Cash

Posts: 2532
Location: Glasgow, Scotland
Blog: View Blog (19)
Gamertag: SE4NQFXD
Console: Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Microsoft Kinect
Fav Game: FIFA 13
Worst Game: Call Of Duty
QuackerJack wrote:
Also, on a small note, when you add up the totals it is a 46.6/50. :wink:

Nice spot :P
I have now changed the total to the correct number!
Thanks!
:D

_________________
Announcements | XLF On Facebook | Follow Me On Twitter | The XLF Team
Feedback & Suggestions | Rules & Information | Work For XLF | Advertise On XLF | XLF Affiliates
Xbox & Kinect Game Reviews: A-Z | Game Talk | Game Battles | Xbox & Kinect Game Achievement Lists: A-Z
Assassin's Creed | Battlefield | Call Of Duty | Dead Island | Far Cry | FIFA | Forza Motorsport | Grand Theft Auto
Gears Of War | Halo | Left 4 Dead | Need For Speed | Pro Evolution Soccer | Resident Evil | Microsoft Kinect Games
Xbox Consoles & Accessories | Microsoft Kinect | Xbox Hardware Modding | Xbox Events, Shows & Magazines
Buy XLF$ Lottery Tickets | Buy XLF$ Shop Items | Tweet For XLF$ | XLF$ Tasks | XLF$ Exchanges
Image
Get Magento Developer | Want gaming traffic to your blog/website? | Scrabble Word Solver
Acne Treatment | Low Cost SEO Solutions | GEO TARGETED WEBSITE TRAFFIC | SQ Drawings | Your Link Here!


Mon Mar 18, 2013 12:50 am
Profile YIM WWW
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 14 posts ] 

Who Is Online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
XboxLiveFan.org: Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group. Designed by ST Software for PTF. Hosted by HostGator.com, Owned by Sean Quinn.