The Xbox Live Fan Posting Competition is currently underway.. Find Out More!
The Xbox Live Fan Prize Prize is currently open for new entrants.. Find Out More!
The Xbox Live Fan Popular Member Competition has opened up for new members to enter.. Find Out More!
Tickets for the XLF$ Lottery (With Special Prize) are now on sale.. Find Out More!
The XLF$ Shop is now open and all orders can be placed.. Find Out More!

Forum rules


All the reviews in this forum have been done by our very own XLF Reviewers. You can request a game review to be done by one of our reviewers by visiting The XLF Team forum and asking one of them to do it. You can view a complete list of all the games reviewed on the Xbox & Kinect Game Reviews: A-Z page. You can not create new topics in this forum, but you can reply to the ones already here. Any posts that break our rules will be removed and the member posting it will be given a warning. If a member accumulates 3 warnings at any one time, they will be banned for life! Each warning given also comes with a 100 XLF Cash deduction for the member receiving it.



Reply to topic  [ 18 posts ] 
 Battlefield 3 (30.0/50) 
Author Message
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
XboxLiveFan.org Game Review On...
Battlefield 3
Buy This Game From Amazon.co.uk


Game Title: Battlefield 3
Game Genre: Action, First Person Shooter
Console(s): Xbox 360, PS3, PC
Publisher: Electronic Arts. Sega (Japan)
Developer: EA Digital Illusions CE
Date Released: October 25th, 2011 – November 2nd, 2011
Retail Price: $60 USD, £40 GBP, $100 AUD.
Age Rating:: PEGI: 16 - USK: 18 – ESRB: M – ACB: MA 15+
Players: Single player, 2-24 online multiplayer
Co-Op: Yes
Achievements: 48 known achievements
Xbox Live Compatable: Yes
Online Multiplayer: Yes
Xbox System Link: No
HDTV Support: Yes – 1.5 GB install.
Previous Edition: Battlefield II

Visuals & Graphics..
The HD graphics really do amp up the game as it should. 1.5 GB of Hard Drive is quite out there for just graphics. But it does make everything a lot more defined and outlined with shadows falling the way they should… But it does add a nice aesthetic finish to the game.

And with the nice HD graphics you’d finally think they’d create a lot more cooler enemies in their respective uniforms, but no. Absolutely not. Most often, enemies are in simple casual wear such as shorts and a t-shirt looking like they were out for a casual walk on the street and figured to join in on all the shootouts on the streets. And while most are simple cut and pasted a few dozen times, they still resemble your own troops. This causes problems when you are low on health and you’re being attacked from all sides and you turn to take an enemy down with you… And all you get is a blatant warning that Friendly Fire will not be tolerated. This can be really frustrating at points and I feel that it may have reduced the enjoyment of the game.

But oh, the lighting… Sometimes you wish you ate enough carrots so that your eyes would pierce the pixelated darkness of the game and see what exactly they’re trying to hide in the shadows and other times you wish you brought a pair of ski goggles. The most annoying thing in all of Battlefield would be its lighting problems. The first mission had shadowy areas mainly since the only light source came from a small knee-high window in one corner, but why not add an extra feature for a flashlight option? Even playing the game with the brightness turned to the max did nothing. The only apparent way to gain a flashlight is to find a weapon that has one mounted AND switched on. But then it always disappears when you swap weapons which completely defeats its purpose. but in other levels, the lighting was so bright that it completely voided my screen and made it impossible to spot oncoming soldiers and whether or not they were dead. One flare in particular was so bright, there were even those light bars that are visible when you try and zoom up close on a bright object. It was a good idea to include extra lighting so that we wouldn’t need a flash light or night vision, but it was a bad screw up to make it so bright, it blinds you.
b]Visuals & Graphics Rating:[/b] 5/10

Achievement Difficulty..
Most achievements in Battlefield 3 are straightforward and can usually be done on the way to other objectives. But to get some of the achievements require thinking outside the box and a good exploration of your environment. Such as one required you to shoot two guys underneath a building before the building collapsed and the other was to push a car off a ledge and squash two cocky rebel soldiers underneath. The car was fun. The shooting of people, not so much.
Achievement Difficulty Rating: 8/10

Story Mode / Campaign Difficulty..
Now this is where all the fun began. To be frank, there is almost no difference in difficulty. Apart from the fact that you can take less shots to the face as the difficulty increases, the game still doesn’t like to ease up on you. In fact, there are many scenarios which involve an unforgiveable instant kill outcome if you so much as crouch behind a barrier. Because snipers in hotel blocks 50 meters back can shoot through concrete barriers and shoot you in the head if you so much as put your head up a millimetre.

The storyline is much reminiscent that of Call of Duty: Black Ops I where the player is kept in an interrogation room and is interrogated by the FBI. It’s not an original storyline as it also involves playing though the game through a means of flashbacks, each one building up to the modern day scene which is hinted at the opening scene of the game. There are other plot ideas that seem to have been taken from Call of Duty also, such as the nuke idea in Call of Duty 4 and the rail airstrokes that are so common with the Modern Warfare series. And frankly, I am disappointed by this. I know Battlefield is better than this and would have better ideas as a driving story plot, but this one is severely disappointing, in my own opinion.
Story Mode / Campaign Difficulty Rating: 5/10

Game Depth & Navigation Details..
As for depth, Battlefield 3 just didn’t suck me in as well as other modern day shooters do. I never felt connected to the protagonist as much as I did to the protagonist in CoD: Black Ops I who I felt the need to actually keep alive and shooting to discover what happened next. The main protagonist in Battlefield 3 seems a lot more distant and far from being involved. The only tones of voice that were variable were angry and neutral/calm which fails to make me interested in the character for that reason. And no interest = no motivation.

Navigation is… tricky. Since Battlefield thinks the idea of destructible cover is such a wonderful idea, all cover, regardless of its actual building material is chipped away with a few placed shots from the enemies. Which always makes you scuttle from car to car and sandbag emplacement to sandbag emplacement but eventually you get picked off by snipers and soldiers with semi-automatic shotguns which are capable of taking you down after three shots on even the easiest difficulty.
In brief, the storyline is but skin deep and the navigation is horrible at times.
Storyline Depth & Navigation Details Rating: 6/10

Value For Money..
I hear the Battlefield fans screaming now about how it’s more of a multiplayer structured game and that you can’t base everything on single player alone. Grated, the multiplayer aspect is what draws many new gamers to it, but don’t players ever feel… bored of repetition?
To me, shooting people on the same map is tiring. When more effort is put into the multiplayer than the single player, a game does lose all interest in me. But I expected more out of Battlefield for the $60 NZD I spent on it and I was disappointed on recycled ideas and themes from other games.
Value For Money Rating: 6/10

Ratings Round-Up..
Visuals & Graphics: 5/10
Achievement Difficulty: 8/10
Story Mode / Campaign Difficulty: 5/10
Game Depth & Navigation Details: 6/10
Value For Money: 6/10

Overall Rating: 30.0/50

Image Image Image


XLF Reviewer: Deadpool

To view the Xbox Game Reviews A-Z, Click Here!
To buy this game from Amazon.co.uk, simply Click Here!
To visit the main Xbox Game Reviews forum, Click Here!

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Sun Jul 29, 2012 4:42 pm
Profile WWW
Growing Up
Growing Up
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
80%

Joined: Thu Jun 21, 2012 9:40 pm
XLF Wallet 10.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 90
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Can't remember... XD
A really good review and I agree with pretty much everything that you have said. :P


Mon Jul 30, 2012 10:56 am
Profile
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
Rhys wrote:
A really good review and I agree with pretty much everything that you have said. :P

Thanks. :cheesygrin:

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Mon Jul 30, 2012 12:43 pm
Profile WWW
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
40%

Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2012 9:54 am
XLF Wallet 20.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 20
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: Original Xbox
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: Fable III
Worst Game: Halo
Great review, Deadpool.
One thing I wasn't sure about was where you got the $100 AUD price. I myself haven't seen it that expensive here on xbox, PC or PS3 but that's just this state so I may be wrong on the typical price but I thought it was worth noting.

No doubt, it's a fun game but I did lose interest in it rather fast sadly. I definitely enjoyed the campaign but you can beat it too damn fast so it becomes a disappoint after that.


Fri Aug 03, 2012 4:39 am
Profile WWW
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
74%

Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2012 3:23 pm
XLF Wallet 31.03 XLF Cash

Posts: 37
Location: Germany
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Ricodonius
Console: Xbox Elite
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: Battlefield 3
Worst Game: Kung Fu Panda
I actually disagree with the graphics & visuals rating. Basically the light blinding you or even the laser is quite realistic compared with other games and even the graphics are outstanding. Call of Duty for example has worse and is even more unrealistic, such as the quick scoping. In reality it would not work.


Fri Aug 03, 2012 3:37 pm
Profile
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
karoshio wrote:
Great review, Deadpool.
One thing I wasn't sure about was where you got the $100 AUD price. I myself haven't seen it that expensive here on xbox, PC or PS3 but that's just this state so I may be wrong on the typical price but I thought it was worth noting.

No doubt, it's a fun game but I did lose interest in it rather fast sadly. I definitely enjoyed the campaign but you can beat it too damn fast so it becomes a disappoint after that.


It's $120 NZD normally. EB Games ran a sale and cut it down to $60 NZD. It's still rather overpriced, IMO. And I normally grab prices off Amazon. So it's perhaps cheaper or whatnot.
But I do agree with you. I lost all interest about 2 hours in.
[EDIT] Although, that may have been the price when it first came out? If I could, I'd re-edit it and put in the proper price but I can't.

Ricus wrote:
I actually disagree with the graphics & visuals rating. Basically the light blinding you or even the laser is quite realistic compared with other games and even the graphics are outstanding. Call of Duty for example has worse and is even more unrealistic, such as the quick scoping. In reality it would not work.


I played with the HD enabled and got about the third level in and was absolutely blinded by a flare that was placed. I had the brightness leveled to the default setting and it was just blinding. Granted it's realistic, but sometimes ridiculous.

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Sun Aug 05, 2012 8:49 am
Profile WWW
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
50%

Joined: Tue Aug 07, 2012 2:53 pm
XLF Wallet 10.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 25
Location: USA
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: xbox 360
Accessory: Skyrim
Fav Game: Halo
Worst Game: Vampire Rain
Great review, a decent game for sure. I would have given more points on the visuals though as I did not think that they were that bad.


Tue Aug 07, 2012 8:14 pm
Profile
Newbie
Newbie
Random avatar
Progress to next rank:
8%

Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2012 6:58 pm
XLF Wallet 20.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 4
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Loven It
This is a really fun game. I enjoy it a lot and can't wait for BF4!


Wed Aug 15, 2012 8:39 am
Profile
Newbie
Newbie
Random avatar
Progress to next rank:
50%

Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2012 6:06 pm
XLF Wallet 10.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 25
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Now I loved this game and thought that the rating you gave it was harsh. Only a 30 out of 50? That seems pretty poor.


Sun Aug 19, 2012 6:08 pm
Profile
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
Austin wrote:
Now I loved this game and thought that the rating you gave it was harsh. Only a 30 out of 50? That seems pretty poor.

I judge it based on my opinion of it. In no way am I biased towards FPS or prefer Call of Duty, but this was how I found it. Regrettably, I didn't enjoy it too much as I could have.

Modern Warfare may be different, and I'm currently saving up in order to gain a copy of it. So we'll see how they stack up.

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:55 am
Profile WWW
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
40%

Joined: Fri Aug 24, 2012 12:37 am
XLF Wallet 20.00 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 0.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 20
Location: Virginia
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: Xbox
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: Black Ops
Worst Game: Socom
I love this game so much, bought it right when it came out


Fri Aug 24, 2012 12:56 am
Profile WWW
Ultimate Fan
Ultimate Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
14.9%

Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:46 am
XLF Wallet 1,094.47 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 13,215.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 2447
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Missriddles
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: Borderlands
Worst Game: Facebreaker
How is it possible that a game like Battlefield 3 gets 30/50? :D Good review, but I don't agree with it all :)

_________________
Image


Thu Sep 20, 2012 4:39 pm
Profile
Established Fan
Established Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.4%

Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:35 am
XLF Wallet 8,271.93 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 6,233.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 662
Location: New Zealand
Blog: View Blog (9)
Gamertag: Flynlocke
Console: Xbox, Xbox 360 Elite
Accessory: Headset
Fav Game: Halo Reach
Worst Game: Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
MissRiddlez wrote:
How is it possible that a game like Battlefield 3 gets 30/50? :D Good review, but I don't agree with it all :)

I graded it on how my own personal experiences with the game. Not being biased or anything, but that is how it was in my honest opinion. It will differ of course from player to player.

And I'm not a CoD fanboy having a go at Battlefield at all. Honest. It's still quite nice.

_________________
Image

Any questions/comments/feedback/reviews you'd like me to do, message me or comment on my team member page! Click on the sig to find it.

Image

And make sure you check out this awesome novel in process written by my girlfriend here!

Check out my new XLF blog called Deadpool's Extras here!


Wed Sep 26, 2012 10:00 am
Profile WWW
Ultimate Fan
Ultimate Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
14.9%

Joined: Fri Jun 15, 2012 11:46 am
XLF Wallet 1,094.47 XLF Cash

XLF Bank: 13,215.20 XLF Cash

Posts: 2447
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: Missriddles
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: Kinect
Fav Game: Borderlands
Worst Game: Facebreaker
Of course not everyone feels the sama about it :) That is the fun of it

_________________
Image


Wed Sep 26, 2012 11:33 am
Profile
Newbie
Newbie
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
22%

Joined: Sat Nov 10, 2012 5:25 pm
XLF Wallet 20.00 XLF Cash

Posts: 11
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Agree With your Review.
But overall i loved this game.


Sat Nov 10, 2012 6:20 pm
Profile
Growing Up
Growing Up
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
52%
1 year of membership
Joined: Mon Feb 20, 2012 8:43 pm
XLF Wallet 60.42 XLF Cash

Posts: 76
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: N/A
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: N/A
Worst Game: N/A
I have to disagree with this review. I love Battlefield 3! It's a really awesome game. I like playing it with friends. And I thought the graphics were pretty decent. :o

_________________
Image
TheMarioForums.com


Fri Nov 16, 2012 6:50 pm
Profile
Growing Up
Growing Up
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
10%

Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2013 10:48 pm
XLF Wallet 209.27 XLF Cash

Posts: 55
Location: South Asia
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: N/A
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: counter strike 1.6
Worst Game: Brian Lare cricket and smack down vs raw all parts
Great game! the cost price deserve more for this game.
such type of games created after long time.


Mon Feb 18, 2013 12:05 am
Profile
Regular Fan
Regular Fan
User avatar
Progress to next rank:
32.7%

Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:06 pm
XLF Wallet 683.51 XLF Cash

Posts: 149
Location: Planet E
Blog: View Blog (0)
Gamertag: N/A
Console: Xbox 360
Accessory: N/A
Fav Game: GTA IV
Worst Game: N/A
Well it seems So Cool, 8-) !!, Will try it once my exams gets finished. :biggrin:


Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:51 pm
Profile WWW
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 18 posts ] 

Who Is Online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
XboxLiveFan.org: Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group. Designed by ST Software for PTF. Hosted by HostGator.com, Owned by Sean Quinn.